Please add support for SFTP
If we are trying to pull PHP devs who work on Linux/Solaris in a corp environment support for ssh is a must. I need to be able to connect webmatrix to my remote systems. FTP is forbidden plain and simple. The fact that it is encouraged through an IDE is down right neglagent on MS part!
Eric
shared this idea
Hello,
Thanks for the feedback. Our recommendation for secure publishing is to use the Web Deploy protocol, but you are right in that SSH/SFTP is used more widely.
23 comments
-
Lars Kemmann
commented
Any word on whether this could possibly make it into version 3?
-
Bill Delaney
commented
Yes, very much a work-in-progress but going well.
-
Sherman
commented
I emailed about that extension, I am very interested in something like that. I'd like to use SCSS on my site without using the command line, so WebMatrix looked perfect. Unfortunately, I need to use SFTP to connect. No reply yet, so I hope that things are still going well...?
-
Bill Delaney
commented
I will be releasing an extension for SFTP publishing in the next 2-3 weeks. I'm looking for beta testers now. If anyone on this thread is interested, please tweet me @dataframes.com, or email developer@dataframes.com
-
Bill Delaney
commented
I have begun work on an extension for Webmatrix to do this. If anyone is interested in being an early beta tester, please contact me asap. I'd be very interested to share the specs, assumptions, etc. Your feedback would be valuable in guiding the beta out the door.
If you are interested in contributing, the project is open source and will be hosted on Codeplex.
-
Amol
commented
When do you think the SSH/SFTP deploy will be ready ? Waiting for it....
-
Frédéric Harper commented
Can't wait to have this feature. It's the only thing I'm missing to be able to use it on my host.
-
Jennifer (WebMatrix Tester)
commented
Hi Jim, if you want to try writing functionality for WebMatrix, you can write an extension. Find out more at http://extensions.webmatrix.com/
-
Jim Dubreville
commented
It should be embarrassing that a product meant for web development work doesn't support the concept of secure file transfer. This product has many benefits but only if you are heavily integrated into the Microsoft stack. That is disheartening given that Microsoft has been getting better at that lately. I guess its back to sublime text.
P.S. Is there anyway I can contribute to the project and build this piece of functionality for you?
-
Gerry
commented
+1
-
Yishai Galatzer [WebMatrix developer] commented
Eric,
The top items at the time we went to implement them where indeed higher on the list. Once an item is marked started or completed it stops getting votes (since votes are limited, people typically choose to vote on what they are not getting yet).
I hope this explains this anomaly you are pointing out
Yishai
-
Eric
commented
Sorry one more item. Looking through the closed items your link pointed out I notice that only a small fraction have more votes then this request.
Let me reiterate one more time non Windows/Azure Server users do not use Web Deploy to migrate their php.
-
Eric
commented
Justin,
Thanks for the follow up. Sorry I had to poke you guys with a stick to get a response on this. I see Microsoft has put a lot of effort into webmatrix and I do see value. The main issue is that Microsoft has to capture more users outside of the specific Windows ecosystem. If I am only a php developer I probably would never consider using webmatrix. You guys need to figure out a way to snag these devs, and I guarantee this feature will be critical to help meet this goal.
If I use an editor like Netbeans, aptana, or even Expression Web I can push to a Linux, or Unix server straight from the Editor. As another commenter mentioned know one wants to break out of their workflow to fire up Filezilla or Putty to push their edits up to their boxes. They will just stop using this editor and switch to one that does.
All the best, and I can't wait to eat some crow!
Eric -
Justin Beckwith
commented
Greetings Eric, and thanks for the feedback. It's unfortunate you're unhappy with the state of the product. I think SublimeText is a fine text editor, if you're just looking for a text editor. We're trying to be a little bit more than that. I see that a third party offers a paid extension for SFTP with SublimeText - out of curiosity, is this what you're using to deploy your sites?
While I understand your frustration, I bristle at the idea that we don't pay as much attention to UserVoice. In WebMatrix 2, we completed 9 of the top 10 requests, among many many others. This feature simply didn't have enough votes at the time. Since we've started this site, we've completed over 150 feature requests from large to small:
https://webmatrix.uservoice.com/forums/128313-webmatrix-suggestions/status/470931If this request continues to gain momentum and stay at the top, we'll build it :) Until then, we offer a rich extensibilty model that may help you achieve the same goal:
http://extensions.webmatrix.com/
Thanks for the continued feedback, and hopefully at some point we'll win you back!
-
Eric
commented
closing in on my anniversary here. Outside of node.js support there is no compelling reason for me to use this toy editor. And, from you comment last year I realize you have no idea what my original issue was. Obviously you cannot use Web Deploy to a linux machine.
I have been using Sublime Text 2 and I would advise anyone who reads this that if you are not using Visual Studio don't bother using this editor. Thanks to everyone who voted this up but I am afraid it is a waste of time. If WebMatrix were on connect this may have been addressed but I don't think the uservoice site is taken as seriously.
-
Emad
commented
Agreed, please add this asap. I need it for Amazon EC2.
-
Eric W
commented
Add my name to the list who would find this feature exceedingly useful.
-
Cian
commented
Web Deploy isn't an option for many (most?) people - SFTP is so widely used and such a critical option that it should really be added asap. This is an otherwise great environment to develop in, but having SFTP still missing is a serious negative. Small update soon?
-
Cat Zoroark
commented
I'm with the folks below. I'm still forced to use FileZilla to deploy my site while using this amazingly simple editor and file manager for actually managing my site. I can't start working on remote tasks until SFTP is implemented.
-
Mike Marcucio commented
too bad, I was looking forward to using this tool but my servers only use sftp
